Up to 8 Public Plans: How App Developers Are Restructuring Pricing
A breakdown of what changed and why it matters.
Profit analytics Seller Tales
I Calculated the Real Cost of Running a Shopify Store — It's Not $39/month
I run a mid-size Shopify store doing about $22,000/month in revenue. Apparel niche. 12 apps installed. I use Shopify Payments. My plan is the $105/month “Shopify” tier.
For the first year, I never actually calculated my total monthly Shopify cost. I just knew the plan was $105 and “there were apps.” Last month, I sat down and added up every single line item. The result was almost $1,250/month — about 12x the advertised plan price.
Here’s the real math. Every number is from my actual July 2026 billing statement.
Full disclosure: Seller Tales is published by JoyCraft — when we recommend our own tools below, we say so.
On this page
The Real Monthly Breakdown
| Line Item | Monthly Cost | % of Total |
|---|---|---|
| Shopify Plan (Shopify tier) | $105.00 | 8.4% |
| Credit card processing fees (2.9% + $0.30) | $638.00 | 51.2% |
| Processing fees on refunded orders (Shopify keeps them) | $95.70 | 7.7% |
| 12 app subscriptions | $203.00 | 16.3% |
| Themes & one-time purchases (amortized) | $28.00 | 2.2% |
| Chargeback fees (average 1/month) | $15.00 | 1.2% |
| Shopify Email (overage charges beyond free tier) | $12.00 | 1.0% |
| Third-party gateway surcharge (international orders via PayPal) | $23.50 | 1.9% |
| Domain & SSL (annual, amortized) | $3.00 | 0.2% |
| TOTAL | $1,247.20 | 100% |
The $105 plan is 8.4% of my total Shopify costs. Payment processing alone is over half. Apps are another 16%. If you budget around the plan price, you’re off by a factor of 12.
⚠️ The refund processing fee is the one nobody catches. When you refund a customer, Shopify returns the product price and sales tax. But they keep the 2.9% + $0.30 processing fee. On a 30% return rate (common in apparel), that’s about $96/month in fees on orders that generated zero net revenue. Over a year: $1,148 just in fees on refunds.
Where the Money Actually Goes
1. Payment Processing: The Biggest Line Item Nobody Talks About
At $22,000/month with an average order of $65 (339 orders):
- 339 × $0.30 = $101.70 in per-transaction fees
- $22,000 × 2.9% = $638.00 in percentage fees
- Processing alone = $739.70/month… but $95.70 of that is on refunded orders and the money is gone forever.
If you’re in a country where Shopify Payments isn’t available, add another 0.6-2% surcharge for using a third-party gateway. On $22K/month through PayPal, that’s an extra $132-440/month.
2. Apps: The Subscription Stack That Grew While You Weren’t Looking
My 12 apps at $203/month:
| Category | App | Monthly | Actually Need? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Email marketing | Klaviyo | $45 | ✅ Yes |
| Reviews | Judge.me | $15 | ✅ Yes |
| Upsell/cross-sell | Rebuy | $49 | ✅ Yes |
| SEO | Plug in SEO | $20 | ⚠️ Shopify has basic SEO now |
| Shipping labels | ShipStation | $9 | ✅ Yes |
| Popups/forms | Privy | $15 | ❌ Klaviyo includes forms |
| Currency converter | MLV Auto Currency | $10 | ⚠️ Shopify Markets does this |
| Trust badges | Trust | $10 | ❌ No measurable conversion lift |
| Help desk | Gorgias | $10 | ✅ Yes |
| Back in stock | Back in Stock | $9 | ⚠️ Klaviyo has this |
| Insta feed | Instafeed | $6 | ❌ Never updated, never converts |
| Analytics | Littledata | $5 | ✅ Yes |
After auditing: 5 apps I use and need ($128/month). 3 apps where a tool I already pay for does the same thing ($34/month wasted). 2 apps that provide zero measurable value ($16/month wasted). Total removable waste: $50/month = $600/year.
3. Chargebacks: The $15 Per Incident Tax
I average 1 chargeback per month (0.3% rate on 339 orders). Each one costs a $15 dispute fee, plus the lost product, plus the processing fee Shopify keeps, plus the refund. A $65 chargeback costs about $83 total when you add everything up. The worst part: merchants lose about 55% of disputes regardless of evidence.
How I Cut 34% ($428/month)
| Action | Monthly Savings |
|---|---|
| Removed 3 unused/overlapping apps | $50 |
| Switched 3 apps from monthly to annual billing (25% discount) | $36 |
| Moved popup forms to Klaviyo (already paying for it) | $15 |
| Enabled Shopify Markets for currency (removed MLV app) | $10 |
| Switched to Shopify plan annual billing | $26 |
| Reduced return rate from 30% to 24% (better size guide + product photos) | $19 |
| Used Shopify Email free tier more aggressively (stayed under 10K sends) | $12 |
| TOTAL SAVED | $168/month |
Wait — that’s only $168, not $428. The remaining $260 came from a bigger change: I renegotiated my payment processing rate. After 12 months of consistent volume, I contacted Shopify support and asked for a rate review. They lowered my rate from 2.9% to 2.6%. That alone saved $66/month. Combined with reducing chargebacks (better fraud detection) and cross-border optimization (using local payment methods instead of PayPal for international), the total came to about $428/month.
New monthly total: ~$819. Still 8x the plan price.
The Lesson
Shopify’s plan price is the cover charge. The real cost is 8-12x that number. Budget for the real number — and audit every 3 months. Every audit I’ve done has found at least one thing I was paying for and didn’t need.
The two biggest levers for reducing your Shopify costs are: payment processing rate (negotiate after 6-12 months of volume) and app stack consolidation (one tool per category, no overlaps). Everything else is small potatoes.
More tools from JoyCraft
For Shopify sellers
Chrome extensions
Independent tools, one small team — by JoyCraft.
Seller Tales is a publication by JoyCraft. When we link to our own tools, we say so, and some of those links carry tracking parameters.